Not comparable — plugins back up different data
Compared by compression ratio — different raw data sizes
These plugins back up different amounts of data — see the Backup Scope badges below. Speed and storage comparisons are not apples-to-apples.
⚠️Different backup scope -- results may not be directly comparable
One plugin backs up more data categories than the other, which affects both speed and archive size.
⚠️ Not backing up wp-config.php or WP core files (wp-admin, wp-includes)
Median backup + restore time broken down by hosting profile.
| Category | All-in-One WP Migration | SafeGuard | Diff | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Files | Size | Files | Size | Files | |
| Database | 1 | 4.6 MB | 1 | 2.8 MB | = |
| Plugins | 10,543 | 119.4 MB | 10,819 | 123.9 MB | +276 |
| Themes | 557 | 18.6 MB | 558 | 18.6 MB | +1 |
| Uploads | 254 | 9.4 MB | 259 | 9.5 MB | |
Iteration 5 (median)
9 iterations across 3 hosting profiles -- median highlighted per profile. Compression shows archive-to-raw ratio (higher = better). * = no compression detected.
| # | Plugin | Backup | Restore | Total | Archive / Raw | Compression | Verify |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | All-in-One WP Migration | 5.7s | 17.3s | 23.1s | 207.0 MBWPRESSnone/ 191.0 MB | 0.9:1* | Verified |
Raw log archive is temporarily unavailable while the benchmark cluster is offline. Metrics, results, and inventories remain downloadable.
⚠️ Not backing up wp-config.php
| +5 |
| WP Core | 0 | 0 B | 2,782 | 57.4 MB | +2,782 |
| wp-config | 0 | 0 B | 0 | 0 B | = |
| Other | 29 | 6.5 MB | 29 | 6.4 MB | = |
| Total | 11,384 | 158.5 MB | 14,448 | 218.6 MB | +3,064 |
SafeGuard | 15.1s | 17.4s | 32.6s | 93.0 MBZIPdefN/ 259.0 MB | 2.8:1 | Verified |
| 2Median | All-in-One WP Migration | 8.5s | 17.1s | 25.5s | 207.0 MBWPRESSnone/ 191.0 MB | 0.9:1* | Verified |
SafeGuard | 14.4s | 18.9s | 33.4s | 93.0 MBZIPdefN/ 259.0 MB | 2.8:1 | Verified |
| 3 | All-in-One WP Migration | 8.9s | 17.9s | 26.8s | 207.0 MBWPRESSnone/ 191.0 MB | 0.9:1* | Verified |
SafeGuard | 15.8s | 19.7s | 35.5s | 93.0 MBZIPdefN/ 259.0 MB | 2.8:1 | Verified |
| # | Plugin | Backup | Restore | Total | Archive / Raw | Compression | Verify |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | All-in-One WP Migration | 3.3s | 17.8s | 21.1s | 207.0 MBWPRESSnone/ 191.0 MB | 0.9:1* | Verified |
SafeGuard | 8.5s | 11.7s | 20.1s | 93.0 MBZIPdefN/ 259.0 MB | 2.8:1 | Verified | |
| 5 | All-in-One WP Migration | 3.2s | 17.4s | 20.7s | 207.0 MBWPRESSnone/ 191.0 MB | 0.9:1* | Verified |
SafeGuard | 8.6s | 11.7s | 20.3s | 93.0 MBZIPdefN/ 259.0 MB | 2.8:1 | Verified | |
| 6Median | All-in-One WP Migration | 3.1s | 17.2s | 20.3s | 207.0 MBWPRESSnone/ 191.0 MB | 0.9:1* | Verified |
SafeGuard | 8.6s | 12.1s | 20.7s | 93.0 MBZIPdefN/ 259.0 MB | 2.8:1 |
| # | Plugin | Backup | Restore | Total | Archive / Raw | Compression | Verify |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 | All-in-One WP Migration | 3.3s | 17.6s | 20.9s | 207.0 MBWPRESSnone/ 191.0 MB | 0.9:1* | Verified |
SafeGuard | 8.3s | 11.5s | 19.8s | 93.0 MBZIPdefN/ 259.0 MB | 2.8:1 | Verified | |
| 8Median | All-in-One WP Migration | 3.4s | 17.3s | 20.7s | 207.0 MBWPRESSnone/ 191.0 MB | 0.9:1* | Verified |
SafeGuard | 8.7s | 11.9s | 20.6s | 93.0 MBZIPdefN/ 259.0 MB | 2.8:1 | ||
| 9 | All-in-One WP Migration | 3.3s | 17.6s | 21.0s | 207.0 MBWPRESSnone/ 191.0 MB | 0.9:1* | Verified |
SafeGuard | 8.6s | 11.8s | 20.4s | 93.0 MBZIPdefN/ 259.0 MB | 2.8:1 | Verified |
| Verified |
| Verified |